I definitely understand why 1 is better to many, but 2's levels are so insanely fun that i can't help but love it more
1 month ago | 12
1 has better atmosphere, 2 has better levels. But neither are lacking in either quality. Overall I pick 2 after somewhat recently playing them back to back
1 month ago | 5
They're both AMAZING games, I could play either one over and over, but Galaxy 1 has better vibes thanks to the Comet Observatory!
1 month ago | 7
Super Mario Galaxy was ground breaking. Super Mario Galaxy 2 was just more of Super Mario Galaxy . Honestly, it felt like DLC that just doubled the size of the first game. Nothing to complain about there!
1 month ago | 1
Galaxy 1 because it's the only mainline Mario game to date that gave us an interesting bit of story (Rosalina's storybook).
1 month ago (edited) | 2
I like Galaxy 2 better ^^ The levels felt even better and I actually loved the planet space ship shaped like Marios face xD Also Yoshi and the Player 2 got an actual character xD But both are great and OG Mario Galaxy will always be great as well ^_^
1 month ago (edited) | 1
While for nostalgia reasons, I wouldn't wanna pick, but for the level design improvements (and to go against the grain), I do actually think the 2nd one is better
1 month ago | 0
There are a lot of things I love about both games that it really hard to find out which one is better, I grew up with both of them.
1 month ago | 1
I like both equally choosing one over the other to me is like picking a favorite child
1 month ago | 0
For me, 1 is better. It has just the right length to not overstay it's welcome, in my opinion, while 2 has a bit too much for my liking
4 weeks ago | 0
I can't pick as I think both games are masterpieces. When I talk about Super Mario Galaxy, I talk about both games as one single entity. Galaxy 1 had the focus on more loneliness galaxies in the dark univerea and how beautiful (and also sad) that world could be while Galaxy 2 is refining what levels in 1 did right and amplifying that level design and experience to a bigger heights. I hate G1 vs. G2 debates or discussions as I boldly state that both shinde with their own light and I am absolutely happy if anyone says they prefer one over the other but saying one is better than the other, for me, is unbelievable.
1 month ago | 0
Mario Galaxy 2 is way better. Yes Galaxy had the better Universe aestetic and vibe, but the level design was on another level in Galaxy 2. I think many people only played Galaxy 1 because it didn't have as many sales on the Wii, and Galaxy 2 wasn't included in 3D All Stars. But if everyone played both games i think its obvious Galaxy 2 is the clear winner. It's btw. my favourite Game of all time
1 month ago | 1
StrawHatMidas
What was better Mario Galaxy 1 or Mario Galaxy 2? (New Video about BOTH Games on the CHANNEL! :D)
1 month ago | [YT] | 99