In 2019, the McClures released their first studio album, The Way Home, recorded in Nashville, Tennessee. The album tells the McClures’ story of finding their way home when the roadmap fails with songs like “Now I See” and “Only Have One.” Paul is featured on several Bethel Music albums, with the most recent being Moments: Wait (2024) leading a reprise of an original song, “Jesus We Love You,” as well as on Simple (2022) singing “Stand In Awe” with Hannah, and the live worship album, Homecoming (2021), leading the song “I Belong To Jesus." He and Hannah are also featured on Bethel Music’s album Have It All (2016) with “Faithful to the End”. Paul co-wrote “For the One” with Jenn Johnson, featured on the Johnson’s solo project, After All These Years (2017), and the live album, Starlight (2017). Paul, along with Hannah, co-authored “God of the Redeemed” with Jeremy Riddle, featured on Bethel Music’s Be Lifted High (2010).